MARK NEWFIELD

Financial Advisor, Managing Director

Collaborative financial planning and business guidance for Richmond area entrepreneurs and executives.

RICHMOND, VA

December 18, 2023
Mark Newfield

The Science of Successful Investing: Understanding Biases for Better Portfolio Decisions

When it comes to managing money, nobody’s perfect. Your relationship with money is molded by the events happening around you — how your parents handled money, financial trauma you may have been exposed to, and major financial events, among others. Most of this molding occurs unconsciously, especially during your early years.

You develop certain biases which can impact your ability to objectively and rationally manage your own money. We don’t often escape our biases. What you can do is be bias-aware. Behavioral biases are a big reason why working with a financial advisor is so helpful. A great advisor will be bias-aware while providing guidance and recommendations so that you get actionable advice that both feels good and is likely to work well.

Understanding Your Behavioral Biases

Some of the most common and impactful biases to be aware of (especially during periods of market volatility) include:

  • Loss aversion bias
  • Confirmation bias
  • Recency bias
  • Herd mentality bias

Let’s take a brief look at each one and discuss what you can do to manage them.

1. Loss Aversion Bias

If you feel more emotionally charged at the thought of losing money than gaining money, you are experiencing loss aversion. Well, congratulations, you are in the majority! Losing money is so painful for many of us that we’re inclined to abandon ship during a market downturn (typically, towards the bottom of the cycle) — rather than ride out the storm and allow your money time to recover and grow again.  

We see loss aversion bias in action all the time, virtually every time the market cycle circles back into a downtrend. Investors panic, sell off stocks, and lock in (sometimes significant) losses — even if historical data trends tell us that staying invested is the better move. Current financial doomerism (read more here) is in many ways being driven by loss aversion resulting from the Great Recession, which ended over 14 years ago.

The key here? Never Interrupt compounding. This might be the single most important thing you can do to create wealth, in combination with systematically saving every time you get paid.

2. Confirmation Bias

As humans, we naturally seek out confirmation of our beliefs, thoughts, and values. It’s why people tend to watch or read news sources that politically lean in the same direction, for example. Along with trying to obtain confirmation of our beliefs, we tend to disregard evidence, opinions, or even data that contradicts them.

When the markets take a turn for the worse, confirmation bias can be especially harmful to investors. Managing your confirmation bias means you must be able to set your beliefs aside and assess the situation objectively. 

Rather than rely on one news source to provide information, gather information from various credible sources and people (including your advisor). It’s natural to want to drown out news opposite to what you believe, but having a broad set of facts, and differing opinions are critical to making informed, forward-focused decisions.

The key here: Constantly seek disconfirming evidence.

3. Recency Bias

Recency bias pushes us to put more emphasis and importance on events or experiences that have happened recently (as opposed to events that happened further in the past).

Post 2008, even after a 68%(!!!) increase in the S and P 500 during 2009, many investors stayed out of the equity markets and missed multi-year, historic gains. The largest inflows into the equity markets were precisely in advance of the Great Recession (during the summer of 2007). The recency of the pre-Great Recession bull market had people piling into stocks at precisely the wrong time. During the spring of 2009, we saw historic flows into bond markets, also at precisely the wrong time.

We see that occurring now, as a great bond push is occurring. Yes, we have what I would consider reasonable bond yields for the first time in ten or so years, and if you are an income investor, moving more money to bonds is smart. At the same time, as of this date, the S&P is up 21% for the year, and if you are overweight bonds right now, you are missing out on a tremendous equity investing year.

The keys: Select a diversified strategy consistent with your time horizon and risk tolerance. Stick with it. Routinely, automatically save into that strategy.

4. Herd Mentality Bias

This is one you’ve likely heard before. People are inclined to follow what others are doing rather than make individual decisions that go against the grain.  Anytime you see headlines about panic selling, that’s herd mentality at play.

Herd mentality is one of the drivers of market timing attempts. Substantial data shows that the great majority of investors fail miserably at market timing and, in fact, time completely wrong by entering markets at the top and exiting at the bottom.

Since 1925, any 20-year rolling period invested in the S&P 500 has had positive returns.  The market rewards those who are patient and disciplined.

The key here: Stick with your strategy, especially when it feels like your strategy is failing.

Remember to Maintain a Long-Term Perspective

Your investment strategy should be built to anticipate market volatility.  Despite investor reactions, volatility is a normal part of the market cycle.  How to manage volatility? Be positioned to ignore it. Maintain an income reserve sufficient to carry you through down markets.

While watching your portfolio trend downward is never fun, it’s important to maintain a long-term perspective. If you “zoom out” and look at the history of the stock market, you’ll see that despite wars, recessions, crashes, crises, political upheaval, and everything else that’s happened in the last 200 years, the market has always trended upward. 

Past performance doesn’t indicate or predict future performance. It is, however, a good reminder that what’s happening right now, or even in the past few years, is highly likely to be a blip when viewed in the timeline of your portfolio.  There is research supporting strategies being “right” over 20 years, even though they were “wrong” for 10 or so years.

If you’re feeling stressed or are tempted to make changes to your plan based on what’s happening in the markets, reach out to your financial advisor. They can walk you through your financial plan and investment strategy, reminding you that safeguards are already in place to protect your desired future.

Need help reviewing your portfolio and navigating market movements? We’re here to help. Reach out today to connect with our team.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

MARK NEWFIELD

Financial Advisor, Managing Director

Mark’s role is primarily as lead advisor and client strategist of his division at JSW. Mark’s passion is ensuring that his team is completely focused on properly caring for you, that you enjoy working with us, and that you receive value from everything the team does for clients.

RESOURCES

Trading’s Toll on Mental Health: The Importance of Discipline and Consistency

by | Feb 20, 2024 | Mark Newfield | 0 Comments

Believe it or not, few forces are more powerful in the trading world than an investor’s mindset. Watching your portfolio shift up and down regularly is challenging, and...

Why Falling Short of Expectations Can Still Be a Success: Lessons from a $52 Million Ferrari Sale

by | Jan 18, 2024 | Mark Newfield | 0 Comments

A 1962 Ferrari 330 LM, owned by Ferrari’s factory team and boasting a Nürburgring class win, was expected to fetch $60 million. But when the auction hammer...

The Science of Successful Investing: Understanding Biases for Better Portfolio Decisions

by | Dec 18, 2023 | Mark Newfield | 0 Comments

When it comes to managing money, nobody’s perfect. Your relationship with money is molded by the events happening around you — how your parents handled money, financial...

How to Assess Your Financial Future in an Uncertain Economy

by | Nov 14, 2023 | Mark Newfield | 0 Comments

When things start shifting — high inflation, geopolitical conflict, unemployment, etc. — chatter about market volatility and economic downturn tends to intensify. But...

The Tech Executive’s Guide to Tax-Efficient Investing in Volatile Markets

by | Oct 4, 2023 | Mark Newfield | 0 Comments

Markets rarely stay steady for long, so it’s important for investors—especially executives at technology firms—to know how to position themselves when it seems like...

The Uncertainty of It All

by | Jun 28, 2023 | Mark Newfield | 0 Comments

Musings on financial and historical uncertainty, with ideas about “Life In the Air Age” Click here to read the full article....