Kristin Bartlow

Financial Advisor, Managing Director

Creating customized financial plans and managing investment portfolios for Bay Area families, entrepreneurs and retirees.

WEST COAST

November 6, 2024
Kristin Bartlow

Retirement Planning: Should You Consider a Step-Up in Basis Instead of a Roth Conversion?

Roth conversions often dominate the tax-efficient retirement planning conversation during lower income years. But another approach might be one to also consider—one that’s often easier to implement and still impactful: the step-up in basis strategy for your taxable investments. 

Understanding the “Sweet Spot” in Retirement

Before we dive into a strategy comparison, it’s important to talk about timing. We often see a window in retirement when your income might be significantly lower; namely, the years between when you stop working and when you must start taking Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) from your retirement accounts.

This dip in income creates a unique opportunity for tax planning.

The More Commonly Discussed Approach: Roth Conversions

First, let’s take a look at the more common strategy for repositioning assets during the low- to no-tax zone period we mentioned above. Roth conversions involve transferring money from a Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. You pay ordinary income tax on the converted amount, but future withdrawals are tax-free. Roth IRAs are also free of RMDs, which inherently decreases taxes in future years by decreasing RMDs.

While a Roth conversion can be an excellent strategy, there are a few challenges and other factors to consider:

  • Taking an immediate tax hit. If you convert, for example, $100,000 from a traditional IRA to a Roth at a 24% tax rate, you’ll be taxed $24,000
  • Your break-even timeline. Typically, you need to live about 15-20 years after the conversion to make it financially worthwhile
  • The primary beneficiaries. Often, it’s the next generation—not you—that ends up the primary beneficiary of a Roth IRA.

Because of these factors, we see only about one in five clients who could benefit from Roth conversions actually following through with them.

A Compelling Alternative: Step-Up in Basis Strategy

Another option for tax-efficient retirement planning is called a step-up in basis strategy. First, a quick explanation and example. Think of your “basis” as what you paid for an investment, or your starting point for measuring gains or losses. 

Imagine you buy 100 shares of a stock for $50 each ($5,000 total). This is your initial basis. Over time, the stock grows to $150 per share, or $15,000 total. 

The embedded gains make it difficult to make the decision to sell the stock when one is in higher income tax years – when you sell the stock, you’ll pay capital gains tax on the $10,000 profit ($15,000 – $5,000). 

This becomes an easier “problem to solve” during the “sweet spot” in retirement, because capital gains tax will be lower than during higher income years. When you execute a “step-up” in basis, you deliberately sell and repurchase an investment to establish a new, higher basis for tax purposes. It’s like hitting the reset button on your cost basis. 

Using our example, let’s say you sell the shares at $150, or $15,000 total, then immediately buy back the same shares at $150. Your new basis is now $15,000 rather than $5,000, and future gains will be calculated from this new, higher price.

When you execute this strategy during lower-income years, you’ll potentially pay little to no capital gains tax on the sale while securing a higher basis for future tax calculations.

Unlike Roth conversions, which we see executed at a rate of about one in every five eligible clients, nearly all of our clients who can leverage the step-up in basis strategy choose to do so. 

While Roth conversions certainly have their place in tax-efficient retirement planning, the step-up in basis strategy often provides a more palatable and immediately beneficial approach to tax management.  A well-crafted, straightforward strategy is often easier to implement, but it still needs to address the complexities of the problem at hand. The key is taking advantage of those lower-income years between retirement and RMDs.

Please share this article with family members or friends who might be entering that window of time between retiring and beginning to take required minimum distributions—they might benefit from understanding an alternative to Roth conversions. 

“Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler.”  -Albert Einstein

 

This material is distributed for informational purposes only. Investment Advisory services offered through Journey Strategic Wealth, a registered investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”). The views expressed are for informational purposes only and do not take into account any individual’s personal, financial, or tax considerations. Opinions expressed are subject to change without notice and are not intended as investment advice. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Please see Journey Strategic Wealth’s Form ADV Part 2A and Form CRS for additional information.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

KRISTIN BARTLOW

Financial Advisor, Managing Director

Kristin is a long-time resident of the Bay Area and has helped hundreds of clients achieve the financial futures they dreamed of. As an experienced financial planner, Kristin speaks the complex language of equity compensation, charitable giving and tax liabilities. She’s devoted to her client base of families and individuals in their 30s, 40s and 50s, knowing that the decisions they make now will have a deep impact on the future they want.

 

RESOURCES

Retirement Planning: Should You Consider a Step-Up in Basis Instead of a Roth Conversion?

by | Nov 6, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

Roth conversions often dominate the tax-efficient retirement planning conversation during lower income years. But another approach might be one to also consider—one...

Will Mortgage Rates Continue to Decrease as the Federal Reserve Cuts Rates?

by | Oct 16, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

In late September 2024, the Federal Reserve made a much-anticipated announcement that they were cutting the Federal Funds Rate by half a percentage point—indicating a...

Worried About High Interest Rates? Finance Your Major Purchases Effectively

by | Sep 4, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

Making a big financial purchase requires smart decision-making at any time, and in the current economic environment, making the wrong choice can have a real impact on...

The Joy of Giving: Advantages of Experience Gifting Over Inheritance

by | Aug 5, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

You know when you read a book and, for whatever reason, it stays with you for a while? I recently read Die With Zero by Bill Perkins, and I’ve found myself continuing...

Are You a Recent Graduate? 7 Tips to Start Your Financial Life Off on the Right Foot

by | Jul 8, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

If you (or someone you know) recently graduated from college, first I’d like to say congratulations! This is such a momentous milestone in your life, and you should be...

How Long Will We See a Yield On Cash?!

by | Jun 6, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

Our economy has certainly been through the wringer these past few years thanks to the onset of COVID-19 coupled with geopolitical upsets, supply chain issues, and other...

Why Is California Experiencing an Insurance Crisis (And How Will it Affect Other States)?

by | May 6, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

Have you recently been told by your home or auto insurer that premiums are increasing? If so, you’re certainly not alone. In fact, Californians are experiencing what...

Not Sure How to Talk to Your Kids About Money? 4 Tips for Getting Started

by | Apr 2, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

Wouldn’t it be great if financial literacy was taught in grade school alongside history and science? Unfortunately, that’s not the case—which means it’s up to us...

2024 Tax Organizer Checklist for Self-Employed Business Owners

by | Mar 8, 2024 | Blog,Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

With April 15 fast approaching, now’s the time to gather up all those tax documents that have been accumulating on your desk and prepare to file. But as a self-employed...

Is It Time to Hit ‘Unsubscribe’? How to Grow Your Savings, Without Sacrificing Your Lifestyle

by | Feb 20, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

In my opinion, few things are more frustrating than discovering someone’s stolen your credit card number. Yet, that’s where I found myself just a few months ago, as I...

New Year, New Limits: Optimizing Your Retirement Savings in 2024

by | Jan 23, 2024 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

The start of a new year often brings fresh perspectives and a renewed focus on personal goals, particularly when it comes to financial well-being. For retirement-minded...

Optimizing Charitable Giving and Taxes Over Your Lifetime: Exploring Strategies Beyond Donor-Advised Funds

by | Dec 5, 2023 | Kristin Bartlow | 0 Comments

Of all the strategies available to investors, charitable giving is pretty unique. How else can you make a meaningful impact and support causes that mean a lot to you...